Kohler Highline VS Cimarron Toilet Comparison 2025

With several Kohler toilet models to pick from, finding the right Kohler toilet for your bathroom is never easy. For this reason, we selected two of the most popular Kohler toilets so that you can compare them and make an informed choice. These are the Kohler Highline two-piece universal height toilet and Kohler Cimarron two-piece elongated bowl toilet. Read this Kohler Highline VS Cimarron comparison to know more about these toilets.

Both of these toilets come with features that most users desire, and they are very excellent in performance. The toilets are durably made, comfortable, easy to set up, elegant, and have some of the best flushing systems. Nevertheless, the unit differs in design and water usage rates. One toilet will help you to save water, and the other will deliver a very powerful and efficient flush.

Features Comparison: Kohler Highline VS Cimarron

Features	Kohler Highline	Kohler Cimarron
Bowl:	Elongated	Elongated
Water Consumption:	1.28 GPF	1.6 GPF
Flush Type:	Water-Saving Toilets	Gravity Flush Toilets
Plug-free flush:	No	Yes
Material:	Vitreous China	China
Premium Slow-Close:	Class Five flushing technology	No
Certification:	WaterSense	No
Dimensions:	31 x 29 x 18 inches	28.8 x 17.6 x 30.8 inches
Price:	Check Price	Check Price

Detail features of the Kohler Highline and Cimarron toilet

If you want to know which toilet will best suit your needs and bathroom style, continue reading this comparison review to the end.

Kohler K-3999-0 Highline Comfort Height Two-Piece Toilet

The Kohler Highline two-piece toilet is a sleek and elegant toilet that will add vigor to any bathroom style. The two-piece toilet is also made of vitreous china, which means that the user will have an easy time setting it up. Also, when it comes to replacement parts, you don’t have to worry as you don’t need to replace the whole unit.

Apart from its stylish design, the Kohler Highline comes with an elongated bowl with a comfort height. So, sitting down or standing up by most adults is not an issue at all. Also, people with mobility problems can use the toilet without strain. And since it is ADA compliant, this toilet can be fitted anywhere. The difficulty that you will face is that it doesn’t feature a toilet seat or wax ring. Because of this, you will have to buy them separately together with a supply line.

Technical features of the Kohler Highline toilet

One of the most outstanding functions of this unit is the class five flushing system. It delivers excellent bulk waste removal, which means that you will not have to flush the toilet twice. With a conveniently located left-hand chrome trip lever, you can even flush the toilet while seated.

Using only 1.28 GPF to clear both solid and liquid waste, this is a high-efficiency toilet that will enable you to save the environment and reduce your water bill.
Check Today’s Price
Pros:

• It features a class five flushing mechanism that eliminates bulk waste very efficiently
• Easy to install
• EPA WaterSense certified
• Comfort height is ideal for most adults
• ADA compliant toilet
• Sturdy construction for longevity
• One-year limited warranty

Cons:

• There is no toilet seat, so, you will have to buy one separately
• The flushing handle is cheaply made

Kohler K-3589-0 Cimarron Comfort Height Elongated Toilet

The Kohler Cimarron two-piece elongated height toilet is another beautiful and straightforward toilet that homeowners would love to have in their bathrooms. The toilet comes with an elegant design that will improve the entire look of your bathroom. Besides, it has five different colors to choose from, which will complement your bathroom theme.

Additionally, the toilet is sturdily made of vitreous china, which is a durable material and simple to clean. China material doesn’t stick substances, which means that the toilet will be easy to clean. The most exciting part is that it comes with the potent AquaPiston flushing system. As a result, water is forced into the bowl from all angles. In the process, it delivers a powerful flush that gets rid of all waste.

Technical features of the Kohler Cimarron toilet

Unlike the Kohler Highline two-piece toilet, this particular unit uses 1.6 GPF. So, it is not suitable if you desire to save water or get rebates in some states. Also, it lacks a toilet seat, which means that you will have to buy one separately, together with the supply line and mounting bolts.

On top of the fantastic features that we’ve just talked about, the user will get great comfort. The elongated bowl and comfort height ensures that different adults and people with mobility issues sit down comfortably and stand up with much ease.
Check Today’s Price
Pros:

• It is a chair height that can provide comfort to many adults
• Durable construction from vitreous china
• Straightforward to install
• It has an elongated bowl that provides added comfort
• The AquaPiston technology delivers an efficient flush every time
• ADA compliant

Cons:

• The toilet seat and supply line are sold separately
• It is not EPA WaterSense certified as it uses 1.6 GPF

Which is better? Kohler Cimarron or Kohler Highline?

After comparing these two Kohler toilets, you should now have an easy time picking a toilet that meets your needs and budget. Both the Kohler Highline and Kohler Cimarron toilets are lovely, durable, comfortable, and feature an efficient flushing system. The main difference between these toilets is the amount of water they use to flush waste.

The Kohler Highline two-piece toilet uses 1.28 GPF, while the Kohler Cimarron two-piece toilet uses 1.6 GPF. So, if you want to save water, then you should consider getting the water-efficient Kohler Highline toilet. But if you want a more efficient flush, then the Kohler Cimarron will be a great option.

Still, have questions after reading this Kohler Highline VS Cimarron comparison? Comment below.

Conclusion

The Kohler Highline and Cimarron toilets both offer excellent performance, comfort, and reliability, making them top choices for any bathroom. While the Highline focuses on classic design and affordability, the Cimarron provides advanced flushing technology and a sleek, modern look. Choosing between them depends on your priorities—whether it’s budget, aesthetics, or enhanced features. Both models represent Kohler’s commitment to quality and durability, ensuring a long-lasting investment for your home.

Frequently Asked Questions

Question: Are both Kohler Highline and Cimarron toilets ADA-compliant?

• Answer: Yes, both models are available with ADA-compliant options, offering comfort height designs for accessibility.

Question: Which toilet has better water efficiency, Highline or Cimarron?

• Answer: The Cimarron typically offers better water efficiency with its AquaPiston flushing system, reducing water usage effectively.

Question: Can I install the Kohler Highline or Cimarron toilets myself?

• Answer: Yes, both models come with straightforward installation guides, but professional help is recommended for optimal results.

Question: Which is more budget-friendly: Kohler Highline or Cimarron?

• Answer: The Kohler Highline is generally more affordable, making it a great choice for budget-conscious buyers.