Kohler vs. American Standard Toilet 2024 [Features Comparison]

With more than 100 years in this field, both American Standard and Kohler toilets offer durable, stylish, and efficient toilets. But which brand offers the best toilets? Some say Kohler, while others say American Standard. Read this Kohler vs. American Standard Toilet article to find out the difference between them.

Both of these toilet brands have a proven track record and can be entirely relied on to deliver an excellent toilet experience. They both offer one-piece toilets, two-piece toilets, elongated bowls, round bowls, and different flushing systems. No matter which brand you select your toilet from, you will get a durable, comfortable, and reliable toilet.

General Differences: Kohler vs. American Standard Toilets

Which brand of toilet should you select? Kohler or American Standard toilet? A basic comparison is here:

Comments	Kohler Toilets	American Standard Toilets
Company Business:	More than 100 years (Parent Est. 1873)	More than 100 years (Parent Est. 1875)
Company Employee:	32,000+	15,200+
Customer Support:	Need Improvement	Very Responsive
Est. Yearly Revenue:	$2 to $5 billion	$500 million to $1 billion
Warranty Support:	Not Great	Very Helpful
Price:	A little bit Higher	Low
Maintenance Cost:	High	Medium
Leak Issues:	Complain Increasing	Still Reasonable
Warranty:	Limited 1-Year Limited Warranty	Limited 10-Year Warranty
My 2024’s Rating:	85 out of 100	90 out of 100
Price:	Check Price	Check Price

In this comparison review, we’ve conducted thorough research to help you have an easy time choosing between American Standard and Kohler toilets.

Details Comparison: Kohler vs. American Standard Toilets

Material of construction

One thing you can be assured of with either Kohler or American Standard toilets is durability. Both toilets are durably made as they feature vitreous china construction. This is a coated ceramic that lasts longer and is easy to clean.

A proper toilet should be able to last for many years, and that’s what you get when you buy a toilet from American Standard or Kohler. That’s one of the reasons why people prefer American Standard, Kohler, or even Toto toilets.

So, in terms of durability, they go head-to-head. As a result, any toilet can do.

Design

Both brands feature beautiful and uniquely constructed toilets. But when it comes to the most appealing toilet designs, Kohler has the edge over American Standard. Whether you’re searching for a contemporary or a conventional toilet, Kohler has all the choices that you may need. Additionally, Kohler offers a broader range of colors, unlike the American Standard, which has limited colors to pick from.

However, the final decision will depend on your taste and bathroom style. Depending on your needs, you may find some American Standard toilets to be more appealing than Kohler toilets.

Flushing performance

American Standard toilets are known to have the best flushing systems (Cadet 3 and Cadet 4 flushing systems) on the market. Because of this, you may not be required to flush the toilet twice, thus, saving water. On the other hand, Kohler toilet users have had complaints about some toilets failing to clear solid waste in a single flush. Depending on the Kohler toilet model that you’ve, you may be required to flush more than once to get rid of solid waste. As a result, you may end up utilizing more water.

Technical Specification of the American Standard Toilets

Feature	American Standard Toilet
Model Number:	2004314.020
Collection:	Champion 4
Color:	White
Material:	Vitreous China
Configuration:	Two-Piece
Bowl Shape:	Elongated
Flushing System:	4″ Accelerator Flush Valve
Flush Type:	Single-Flush
Flush Rate:	1.6 GPF (gallons per flush)
Trapway Size:	2-3/8″ Fully Glazed
Rim Height:	16-1/2″ ADA Compliant
Overall Height:	31-1/8″
Overall Width:	17-7/8″
Overall Depth:	28-1/2″
Seat Included:	Yes, Slow-Close EverClean Surface with Easy Lift-Off
Trip Lever Location:	Left-hand Side
Rough-in:	12″ Standard
Certifications & Compliance:	ADA, ASME A112.19.2-2008/CSA B45.1-08, EPA WaterSense
Warranty:	10-Year Limited Warranty on Chinaware; 5-Year Limited Warranty on All Mechanical Parts; 1-Year Limited Warranty on Seat
Price:	Check Today’s Price

Pros:

• High-efficiency models save water, reducing utility bills.
• Durable construction ensures longevity.
• Variety of designs to fit different bathroom styles.
• Some models feature innovative flushing systems for better cleanliness.
• Easy to clean surfaces.

Cons:

• Higher-end models can be expensive.
• Limited color options compared to some other brands.

The only complaint that American Standard users have had about their flushing systems is the sticking of substances at the back of the toilet. Some American Standard flushing systems are not sufficient and leave waste marks after flushing. So, you may have to clean your toilet more often than expected.

Ease of cleaning

This depends on whether the toilet is a two-piece or one-piece unit. Generally, one-piece toilets are simple to clean than two-piece toilets. If you want a toilet that won’t give you a headache to clean, then consider going for a one-piece unit. Such toilets don’t have a gap between the tank and bowl where mold, mildew, and bacteria grow from.

When it comes to these two brands, you can say that American Standard toilets are easier to clean as most of them feature an EverClean surface, while Kohler doesn’t. The EverClean surface keeps the toilets clean for longer by preventing the sticking of stains and waste on the bowl.

However, even without a special coating, most Kohler toilets don’t allow substances to stick to the bowl. And that’s why you don’t hear people complaining about Kohler toilets being hard to keep clean. Actually, Kohler toilets are easier to keep clean as the AquaPiston flushing system pushes everything down the drain. This is not the same case with the class five flushing system, which tends to leave waste marks at the back of the toilet.

Technical Specification of the KOHLER Cimarron Comfort Height Toilet

Feature	KOHLER Cimarron Toilet
Dimensions:	28.75 x 17.62 x 30.75 inches
Weight:	65.3 pounds
Color:	Biscuit
Material:	Vitreous China
Shape:	Elongated
Installation Method:	Floor Mounted
Flush Type:	Gravity Flush
Flush Technology:	AquaPiston
Flush Performance:	Class Five
Water Consumption:	1.28 gallons per flush (GPF)
WaterSense Certified:	Yes
Trapway Size:	2-1/8 inches
Bowl Height:	Comfort Height (17-19 inches)
Seat Included:	No
Handle Location:	Left side
Rough-in:	12 inches
Warranty:	One-Year Limited Warranty
Certifications & Compliance:	ADA, ASME A112.19.2/CSA B45.1, EPA WaterSense, ICC/ANSI A117.1
Price:	Check Today’s Price

When thinking about the ease of cleaning the toilet, also consider picking a toilet with a skirted design. Both American Standard and Kohler toilets have different models on offer.

Pros:

• The efficient flushing system with AquaPiston technology ensures a powerful and consistent flush.
• Comfort Height design makes sitting down and standing up easier for most adults.
• Durable construction and high-quality materials for long-lasting use.
• Water-saving with 1.28 gallons per flush, meeting EPA WaterSense criteria.
• Easy installation process.

Cons:

• Higher price point compared to standard models.
• The bulkier design may not fit well in smaller bathrooms.
• Some users may prefer a more traditional flush mechanism.

Ease of installation

You will never have an issue installing any of the toilets. Of course, unless it is a one-piece toilet with a skirted bowl. These tend to be more challenging to install than ordinary toilets. Also, one-piece toilets are slightly heavier and thus more challenging to install than two-piece units.

Comfort

If comfort is what you’re looking for, then you can never go wrong with Kohler toilets. The brand offers the best-elongated bowl toilets on the market. Also, most of their toilets are of chair height, which means that they can accommodate different users without any issues. This doesn’t mean that American Standard toilets are not comfortable, but when compared to Kohler toilets, it has the edge over them.

Price

Price-wise, American Standard offers the most affordable toilets among the best three brands. That’s American Standard, Kohler, and Toto. Therefore, if you want a quality toilet at an excellent price, then American Standard is the brand to consider.

Affiliate Disclosure: “We may get a small commission when you buy through our links at no extra cost as this page contains Amazon affiliate links.”

Two-Piece Unit: Kohler Cimarron vs. American Standard Cadet Pro

One-Piece Unit: American Standard Champion 4 vs. Kohler San Souci

Which brand is better? American Standard or Kohler?

After comparing these two brands, it is safe to say that American Standard has the edge over Kohler. American Standard offers the best designs, comfort, and their toilets are easy to clean. And also, American Standard has the best flushing systems, and their toilets are cheaper.

On the other hand, when it comes to overall durability, people have had a lot of complaints about Kohler toilets. But if you want a reliable, durable, comfortable, and efficient toilet, Kohler is the best choice to choose from.

Related Comparison Articles:

• Comapre Kohler Veil with Toto Neorest Toilet
• Differences between Kohler Highline and Cimarron toilets

Jose S. Franz

Hi, I am Jose S. Franz. Currently, I am working as a professional plumber, and our team offers various plumbing services at an affordable price. After my college education, I completed a vocational certification course in plumbing systems and worked with several construction companies. Since then, I have fixed lots of different toilet models, from older to the latest versions. So I have more than 22 years of experience installing plumbing systems and toilets in both residential and commercial buildings.